mother-baby

Does Daycare Cause Attachment Issues?

Table of Contents
    Add a header to begin generating the table of contents

    For a very long time, parents, lawmakers, and developmental academics have been wondering if and how children's time spent with caregivers other than their mothers affects their growth and development.

    For as long as anybody can remember, ever since Bowlby popularised attachment theory, some have assumed that daycare, particularly when started in the infant's first year, will threaten the stability of the infant's attachment to his or her parents.

    It was speculated that this was because infants had to be separated from their mothers (or primary caregivers) when they started attending daycare, and that this was inherently stressful for them.

    The degree to which a mother can provide emotionally supportive care for her kid is the most important factor in determining the degree of danger to which that child is exposed; separation can make it more difficult for her to do so, which in turn can raise the risk (i.e., separation-insensitivity-insecurity).

    To conclude, we should expect a connection between daycare and attachment security because, as we saw before, security was a reflection of general emotional well-being, and the negative impacts of daycare on infants would show up as insecure attachment later on.

    To What Does One Feel Attached?

    For the sake of everyone involved, Child Care Today is dedicated to doing things the right way.

    According to British psychologist Penelope Leach, a child's mother is the first "attachment figure" they have for biological reasons. Mothers aren't the only potential caregivers, though.

    Despite what many may believe, Leach argues that children can have attachments to their fathers (and other loving caregivers) that are distinct from, and not a replacement for, their attachment to their mothers.

    The "father of attachment theory," British psychiatrist John Bowlby, and "mother of attachment theory," American psychologist Mary Ainsworth, co-wrote the book "Attachment and Loss," which highlights the significance of the first infant/mother interaction in historical research. He came to the conclusion that a child needs a stable home life in order to flourish as a student.

    Destructive behaviours in kids may be a sign that our culture isn't doing enough to support their attachment development.

    I began my career in the education sector over twenty years ago, first as a school social worker and later as a parent educator.

    I worked with students and their families from elementary school all the way through high school.

    Many of the gifted children I knew back then also suffered tremendously from emotional, behavioural, and psychiatric issues.

    The developmental psychologist Gordon Neufeld identified three stages of child development: first, parents should work on cultivating a healthy attachment with their children; second, children should mature (within the context of a stable attachment); and third, children should begin to engage in socialisation.

    Looking for an early learning centre in Sydney ? Then Little Angels early learning centre  is what you’re looking for. 

    Developing Reactive Attachment Disorder: Is it Avoidable?

    What Causes RAD?

    Reactive attachment disorder can occur in young children who get inadequate care and minimal emotional response from their caregivers.

    This increases the likelihood that the child may acquire RAD.

    Researchers have found that the severity of withdrawal symptoms is proportional to the duration of the underlying deprivation.

    The most common reason is neglect, but there are various ways in which a caregiver can fall short of what's needed to keep a child safe and healthy.

    • In the event that a youngster is neglected by his or her caregivers and does not receive enough love, attention, or activity: A child always needs mental and emotional stimulation as well as physical love and care. An attachment disorder may develop in a youngster who is deprived of any of the following: physical touch, food, baths, or social interactions. One or more of these changes can lead to this condition. Neglect also manifests itself when a child is regularly left unsupervised in a crib or playpen, when late-night feedings are skipped, or when the infant is not interacted with at all.

     

    • Instability in primary attachment figures because of frequent changes in primary caregivers: It's not easy being a parent, and it might be especially difficult if you have a full-time job or are parenting your child by yourself. There's no denying the importance of babysitters and daycares, but frequent changes aren't recommended. Frequent changes in babysitters, daycare providers, or nannies might add to the emotional upheaval the child is experiencing as a result of the disruption in their routine. For kids to feel safe and trust their caretakers, they need routines and long-term interactions with the same individual.

     

    • To be cared for in settings where connection formation is discouraged: If one or both of a child's parents are behind bars or in and out of the hospital regularly, the court may order the youngster to live in a foster home or another temporary living arrangement. Children in foster care may be relocated frequently. This hinders the child's capacity to form a secure bond to the caretaker and causes problems with self-care.

    Risk Factors for RAD

    Neglect or disinterest from others

    • Being brought up in a group setting like an orphanage or other institution
    • Forcibly removed from a home where there is abuse or neglect and placed in a series of foster homes
    • What it's like to have a mother who suffers greatly from postpartum depression after giving birth.
    • Having a primary caretaker through multiple instances of devastating loss or major life transitions

    Preventing RAD

    Even in cases where it seems impossible, such when parents adopt or foster their children, RAD can be prevented.

    The primary responsibility for preventing RAD is with the child's biological parents or primary caregivers, who must ensure that the youngster has many opportunities for social interaction, physical affection, and intellectual challenge.

    Unfortunately, some parents are unable to do so because they themselves are battling mental health issues or substance abuse.

    The seriousness of the repercussions for their child necessitates that they seek help from a trained professional without delay.

    Caregivers can reduce the risk of reactive attachment disorder in infants by providing them with consistent, loving emotional stimulation from an early age. The following are examples of possible emotional manifestations:

    • Keeping eye contact throughout
    • It's important to adapt your facial and vocal emotions to your baby's mood.
    • Cutting down on time wasters like electronic gadgets
    • Sharing in the duties of caring for the child by helping with things like diaper changes and bath time.
    • Making a baby happy by singing to or for it
    • Grinning at the infant.
    • The tiny youngster and I are having a good time.

    Get Help for Yourself

    family-child-field

    Caring for a child with RAD can be incredibly challenging, so it's important to prioritise your own health and wellbeing as a parent.

    If your child has been diagnosed with reactive attachment disorder, meeting other parents through a community group, self-help group, or support group can be a great resource (RAD).

    If you want to be a good role model and parent to your child, you need to take care of yourself first.

    This includes having fun, staying physically active, and getting adequate sleep.

    See our list of available early learning programs Sydney to help you make an informed decision for your child. 

    As a clinical content writer with a medical degree, Kristen Fuller, M.D., is interested in writing about evidence-based issues connected to the most cutting-edge areas of mental health and addiction medicine.

    She has made important contributions to the education of medical board members as a family physician, author, and university lecturer.

    She has made it her life's work to combat the discrimination that people with mental illness and other avoidable illnesses face. She spends most of her leisure time encouraging other ladies to explore the great outdoors.

    Developing Healthy Attachments in Any Setting

    Eliminating a parent's income as a means of addressing a child's attachment disorder is not a good idea.

    Instead, it is the job of every caregiver a child has, including parents, grandparents, nannies, and daycare employees, to assist the child form trusting relationships with caring adults.

    Neufeld proposes bringing back the idea of the attachment village from past generations to assist youngsters in establishing and maintaining bonds with several adult caregivers.

    When forming your attachment network, bear in mind the following six guidelines.

    • As a first step in creating a secure parent-child attachment, Neufeld recommends parents encourage their children to form relationships with other caring individuals outside of the immediate family. It's great to have so many caring grownups in your kid's life. While kids make friends in their neighbourhoods, they feel more at ease when they're away from home.

     

    • Gain the caregiver's trust. Spending time with the caretaker in whatever setting you use will show your child how much you value and trust them. The youngster will learn to trust the caretaker if they observe their parents getting along well with them.

     

    • Make sure the caregiver understands and practises attachment theory. Caretakers should proactively bring their charges inside. Neufeld recalls with fondness the enthusiastic greeting he received from his first grade instructor. He says that welcoming our kids into your circle of friends is like "gathering" them. 

     

    • Realise that bonds to various adults do not threaten one another. One may say that they work together. One thing that both adults and children need to keep in mind is that developing a connection to a friend or significant other does not necessarily entail growing distant from one's parents. Both the care provider and the parent can express their appreciation by praising the other." We are an attachment relay team whose responsibility it is to ensure that the child is always in the care of an adult. To ensure a smooth handoff of the attachment baton, we must first verify that it has been properly passed.

     

    • Taking your time in the morning will ensure that young children are not hurried out the door. Gordon Neufeld describes the significance of getting up with his kids ten minutes early in an article he wrote: "Two of the plush seats in our living room are set aside as "warm-up chairs." My wife Joy and I sat the boys on our laps as soon as they woke up and held them, played with them, and joked with them until their attention was captured, their grins emerged, and their nods became effective. The situation improved greatly afterwards. It was time well spent to rise ten minutes earlier and engage in this collecting routine before launching into full-on parenting mode.

     

    • You can help your child feel your love even when you're separated by giving them a locket or other memento with your photo on it. A daytime phone call or sweet note might go a long way towards maintaining this bond. Caregivers' hectic schedules may prevent them from doing the latter. Ideals, however, matter regardless of whether or not they are achievable within the context of the care systems we have developed. Parents who are able to share as much information as they can with their kids about what they do at work are also helpful. It's something we do with the people we care about, and it's good for kids if they can grasp (to the extent possible) what their parents do for a living.

    According to research conducted by the National Institute of Child Health and Youth Development, mother-child bonding is shaped more by regular family activities than by childcare.

    Most significantly, they found "virtually little evidence showing that child outcomes were associated with whether or not the child experienced routine child care" across cognitive, linguistic, and social domains at ages 2, 3, and 41.2. What seemed to make a difference, though, is the current question.

    Interactions between a mother and her child, including their characteristics, frequency, and stability.

    Having a healthy relationship with your child is good for both of you, so you shouldn't worry too much about your child's daycare breaking the bond you've fought so hard to build.

    A secure attachment with your child can make a world of difference in the long run, and the website Psych Central offers a variety of tips for developing that bond with your child.

    By doing things like showing affection, reacting to your infant's distress, and keeping to a consistent routine, you can feel certain that the bond you have with your child is meaningful and close.

    You can accomplish all of these goals in many other methods besides the ones listed here.

    Knowing how the parent-child bond is established might help ease the fears of nervous parents who are hesitant to leave their child at daycare.

    Focus on the positive aspects of your time together instead of worrying about what could go wrong.

    If you and your child spend some quality time together and you both learn as much as possible about the various facets of this common anxiety, you may both feel more prepared for the transition to daycare.

    How to Parent for a Secure Attachment and How to Know if It’s Working

    The importance of the infant realising their own value cannot be overstated. A caretaker must be invested, aware, compassionate, and sensitive to the person they are caring for.

    Here's how Sroufe explains it: "The baby will instruct you what to do." "They don't have a lot of methods to express what they need, but if they're being obnoxious, it's easy to figure out what it is they want. They are requesting to be taken up if they put out their arms.

    Furthermore, if you fail to correctly read their signals, they will keep doing so until you do." As an example, he talks about bottle feeding a baby: "While she glances about, she mulls over whether or not the baby needs a break. So what does the toddler require in order to take a good look?

    The baby may demand and the parent may find that she snaps her head away or pulls away more forcibly if she misreads and tries to put the bottle back into her mouth."

    If you're looking for an Early Learning Centre Sydney that develops children's unique capabilities, you’re in the right place. 

    A client of mine who had been carrying her child for six months wanted to know, "How can I determine whether my kid is securely attached?"

    Although the signs of a good attachment are not clearly obvious until about nine months after birth, they are nonetheless present:

    0-3 months:

    watercolors
    • The newborn's physiological rhythms are barely settling as the baby switches rapidly between feeding, sleep, and alert vigilance. Providing for the baby's requirements across the cycle aids in doing so.
    • There is no evidence that the infant favours one caregiver over another at this time.
    • The infant is content and aware, taking in the sights and sounds of her environment.

    4-8 months:

    • The baby normally responds well to attempts at relaxing her. (Warning: an inability to soothe may indicate something other than insecurity.)
    • The primary caregiver enjoys pleasant exchanges with the baby.
    • The newborn exhibits phases of serenity and exploration of her environment. To the extent that she is able, she looks, grasps, reaches, babbles, begins to crawl, examines items by putting them in her mouth, hands, etc.
    • Infants develop the ability to tell people apart and indicate preferences soon after birth. They are more likely to show their emotions (smiles, tears) to the caretaker, yet they are still curious about unfamiliar people.
    • They take a keen interest in the persons they see frequently, especially their siblings.

    9 months:

    • The newborn clearly favours one major caretaker above the others.
    • The degree to which the newborn is wary of strangers varies with temperament.
    • The infant's disposition makes her anxious when she is separated from her primary caregiver.
    • After being separated from mum and dad, the baby quickly calms down and is ready to continue her previous activities.

    9 months – 3 years:

    • The kid obviously has strong feelings for one main person.
    • The child maintains tight contact with that individual but also develops strong bonds with others who are frequently present in his or her life, such as a babysitter or siblings.

    As parents, one of the most challenging tasks we have is maintaining a secure grip on our children, especially in the formative years.

    Ultimately, children want to remain with their parents and look up to them, therefore, nature is on the side of parents.

    Parents may choose to take advantage of this opportunity. In contrast to formal education, children reportedly learn more in their first four years of life from unstructured activities.

    Children's academic potential can only blossom in settings that encourage positive peer interactions (attachments).

    Raising children with an adult perspective and a strong sense of attachment to responsible adults is crucial, but far more so than most parents and other caregivers realise.

    Being without the necessary child care only heightens the seriousness of the problem.

    The good news is that we can all work towards more attachment and children who are more adult-oriented, regardless of the care that a child receives.

    Conclusion

    Some have assumed that daycare threatens the stability of an infant's attachment to their parents. According to British psychologist Penelope Leach, a child's mother is the first "attachment figure" they have for biological reasons.

    Despite what many may believe, Leach argues that children can have attachments to their fathers (and other loving caregivers).

    Reactive attachment disorder can occur in young children who get inadequate care and minimal emotional response from their caregivers.

    Parents should work on cultivating a healthy attachment with their children.

    Frequent changes in babysitters, daycare providers, or nannies might add to the emotional upheaval the child is experiencing as a result of the disruption in their routine.

    To be cared for in settings where connection formation is discouraged.

    If one or both of a child's parents are behind bars, the court may order the youngster to live in a foster home.

    This hinders the child's capacity to form a secure bond to the caretaker and causes problems with self-care.

    Sydney-based psychotherapist Dr Richard Neufeld says it is the job of every adult to help children form trusting relationships with caring adults.

    This includes having fun, staying physically active, and getting adequate sleep.

    See our list of available early learning programs Sydney to help you make an informed decision for your child.

    Taking your time in the morning will ensure that young children are not hurried out the door.

    Developing a connection to a friend or significant other does not necessarily mean growing distant from one's parents. A daytime phone call or sweet note might go a long way towards maintaining this bond.

    Mother-child bonding is shaped more by regular family activities than by childcare.

    Focus on the positive aspects of your time together instead of worrying about what could go wrong.

    If you and your child spend some quality time together, you may both feel more prepared for the transition to daycare.

    From 0-3 months, the baby will instruct you what to do, and if you fail to correctly read their signals, they will keep doing so until you do.

    Children's academic potential can only blossom in settings that encourage positive peer interactions (attachments).

    Raising children with an adult perspective and a strong sense of attachment to responsible adults is crucial, but far more so than most parents realise.

    The good news is that we can all work towards more attachment and children who are more adult-oriented, regardless of the care they receive.

    Content Summary

    • For a very long time, parents, lawmakers, and developmental academics have been wondering if and how children's time spent with caregivers other than their mothers affects their growth and development.
    • For as long as anybody can remember, ever since Bowlby popularised attachment theory, some have assumed that daycare, particularly when started in the infant's first year, will threaten the stability of the infant's attachment to his or her parents.
    • It was speculated that this was because infants had to be separated from their mothers (or primary caregivers) when they started attending daycare, and that this was inherently stressful for them.
    • According to British psychologist Penelope Leach, a child's mother is the first "attachment figure" they have for biological reasons. Mothers aren't the only potential caregivers, though.
    • Despite what many may believe, Leach argues that children can have attachments to their fathers (and other loving caregivers) that are distinct from, and not a replacement for, their attachment to their mothers.
    • Destructive behaviours in kids may be a sign that our culture isn't doing enough to support their attachment development.
    • Many of the gifted children I knew back then also suffered tremendously from emotional, behavioural, and psychiatric issues.
    • The developmental psychologist Gordon Neufeld identified three stages of child development: first, parents should work on cultivating a healthy attachment with their children; second, children should mature (within the context of a stable attachment); and third, children should begin to engage in socialisation.
    • Reactive attachment disorder can occur in young children who get inadequate care and minimal emotional response from their caregivers.
    • This increases the likelihood that the child may acquire RAD.
    • Instability in primary attachment figures because of frequent changes in primary caregivers: It's not easy being a parent, and it might be especially difficult if you have a full-time job or are parenting your child by yourself.
    • There's no denying the importance of babysitters and daycares, but frequent changes aren't recommended.
    • For kids to feel safe and trust their caretakers, they need routines and long-term interactions with the same individual.
    • To be cared for in settings where connection formation is discouraged: If one or both of a child's parents are behind bars or in and out of the hospital regularly, the court may order the youngster to live in a foster home or other temporary living arrangement.
    • Children in foster care may be relocated frequently.
    • This hinders the child's capacity to form a secure bond to the caretaker and causes problems with self-care.
    • The primary responsibility for preventing RAD is with the child's biological parents or primary caregivers, who must ensure that the youngster has many opportunities for social interaction, physical affection, and intellectual challenge.
    • Caregivers can reduce the risk of reactive attachment disorder in infants by providing them with consistent, loving emotional stimulation from an early age.
    • Caring for a child with RAD can be incredibly challenging, so it's important to prioritise your own health and wellbeing as a parent.
      If your child has been diagnosed with reactive attachment disorder, meeting other parents through a community group, self-help group, or support group can be a great resource (RAD).
    • As a clinical content writer with a medical degree, Kristen Fuller, M.D., is interested in writing about evidence-based issues connected to the most cutting-edge areas of mental health and addiction medicine.
    • Eliminating a parent's income as a means of addressing a child's attachment disorder is not a good idea.
    • Instead, it is the job of every caregiver a child has, including parents, grandparents, nannies, and daycare employees, to assist the child form trusting relationships with caring adults.
    • Neufeld proposes bringing back the idea of the attachment village from past generations to assist youngsters in establishing and maintaining bonds with several adult caregivers.
    • When forming your attachment network, bear in mind the following six guidelines.
    • As a first step in creating a secure parent-child attachment, Neufeld recommends parents encourage their children to form relationships with other caring individuals outside of the immediate family.
    • It's great to have so many caring grownups in your kid's life.
    • Gain the caregiver's trust.
    • Spending time with the caretaker in whatever setting you use will show your child how much you value and trust them.
    • Make sure the caregiver understands and practises attachment theory.
    • Realise that bonds to various adults do not threaten one another.
    • One thing that both adults and children need to keep in mind is that developing a connection to a friend or significant other does not necessarily entail growing distant from one's parents.
    • Both the care provider and the parent can express their appreciation by praising the other."
    • We are an attachment relay team whose responsibility it is to ensure that the child is always in the care of an adult.
    • To ensure a smooth handoff of the attachment baton, we must first verify that it has been properly passed.
    • Taking your time in the morning will ensure that young children are not hurried out the door.
    • Gordon Neufeld describes the significance of getting up with his kids ten minutes early in an article he wrote: "Two of the plush seats in our living room are set aside as "warm-up chairs."
    • It was time well spent to rise ten minutes earlier and engage in this collecting routine before launching into full-on parenting mode.
    • You can help your child feel your love even when you're separated by giving them a locket or other memento with your photo on it.
    • Parents who are able to share as much information as they can with their kids about what they do at work are also helpful.
    • It's something we do with the people we care about, and it's good for kids if they can grasp (to the extent possible) what their parents do for a living.
    • According to research conducted by the National Institute of Child Health and Youth Development, mother-child bonding is shaped more by regular family activities than by childcare.
    • Interactions between a mother and her child, including their characteristics, frequency, and stability.
    • Having a healthy relationship with your child is good for both of you, so you shouldn't worry too much about your child's daycare breaking the bond you've fought so hard to build.
    • A secure attachment with your child can make a world of difference in the long run, and the website Psych Central offers a variety of tips for developing that bond with your child.
    • By doing things like showing affection, reacting to your infant's distress, and keeping to a consistent routine, you can feel certain that the bond you have with your child is meaningful and close.
    • Knowing how the parent-child bond is established might help ease the fears of nervous parents who are hesitant to leave their child at daycare.
    • Focus on the positive aspects of your time together instead of worrying about what could go wrong.
    • If you and your child spend some quality time together and you both learn as much as possible about the various facets of this common anxiety, you may both feel more prepared for the transition to daycare.
    • How to parent for a secure attachment and how to know if it's working.
    • The importance of the infant realising their own value cannot be overstated.
    • They don't have a lot of methods to express what they need, but if they're being obnoxious, it's easy to figure out what it is they want.
    • Although the signs of a good attachment are not clearly obvious until about nine months after birth, they are nonetheless present:
    • The newborn's physiological rhythms are barely settling as the baby switches rapidly between feeding, sleep, and alert vigilance.
    • Providing for the baby's requirements across the cycle aids in doing so.
    • The primary caregiver enjoys pleasant exchanges with the baby.
    • The infant's disposition makes her anxious when she is separated from her primary caregiver.
    • After being separated from mum and dad, the baby quickly calms down and is ready to continue her previous activities.
    • The kid obviously has strong feelings for one main person.
    • The child maintains a tight contact with that individual but also develops strong bonds with others who are frequently present in his or her life, such as a babysitter or siblings.
    • As parents, one of the most challenging tasks we have is maintaining a secure grip on our children, especially in the formative years.
    • Ultimately, children want to remain with their parents and look up to them, therefore, nature is on the side of parents.
    • Parents may choose to take advantage of this opportunity.
    • In contrast to formal education, children reportedly learn more in their first four years of life from unstructured activities.
    • Children's academic potential can only blossom in settings that encourage positive peer interactions (attachments).
    • Raising children with an adult perspective and a strong sense of attachment to responsible adults is crucial, but far more so than most parents and other caregivers realise.
    • Being without the necessary child care only heightens the seriousness of the problem.
    • The good news is that we can all work towards more attachment and children who are more adult-oriented, regardless of the care that a child receives.

    FAQs About Attachment Issues

    Available data indicate that, for most children, parental attachment processes are not disrupted by daycare participation. ... In fact, for some children, secure attachment with caregivers in daycare may compensate for the adverse effects of insecure parent-child relations.

    According to research, enrollment in a high-quality daycare center can have a significant, long-lasting impact on children's social and emotional development. Consistent socialization and play in early childhood have been associated with higher levels of empathy, resilience, and prosocial behavior later in life.

    Insecure attachments develop if early interactions between a child and their caregiver are negative, inconsistent, inappropriate, neglectful or abusive. When a child's care giver and home environment is a source of fear rather than a source of safety, this can be highly toxic to a child's development.

    Causes. No one knows exactly why some children develop attachment disorders while others living in the same environment don't. But researchers agree there is a link between attachment disorders and significant neglect or deprivation, repeated changes in primary caretakers, or being reared in institutional settings.

    Attachment is formed when a parent responds to their child's needs in a manner that is warm, sympathetic, and consistent. This is of the utmost significance whenever your infant is ill, upset, or otherwise distressed. As you go about your everyday routines with your baby, providing care for them and engaging with them, the bond that you have with them will also grow.

    Scroll to Top
    Scroll to Top